Top 10 Movie Lists Movie Reviews Awards & Oscars Box Office TV Series

Communists Complain About Indiana Jones 4 – Really?

Share:

Indiana Jones 4Oh, those silly little Soviets. One may think that communism is dead in Russia, or not if you watch as Vladimir Putin moves “his country” closer and closer to a KGB-esque version of democracy, but regardless of what he denies, there still is a Communist Party in Russia, and they allegedly want to return Russia to the glory years of the Soviet Union.

OK, that may be a sweeping generalization of Russia’s Communist Party. The Red Scare is all but over, and people have their right to whatever political beliefs they may hold. There’s nothing inherently evil about communism, though the implementation of such ideals have never appeared to be as glorious as Karl Marx had foreseen. And when it comes to Russia, communism has a pretty bad track record. That being said, I’m sure there are the moderates and the extremists within Russia’s Communist Party, but you wouldn’t guess from this Reuters article about Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.

According to the article, Russian Communists aren’t too happy about the depiction of their brethren in the latest Indiana Jones movie, so much so that they are calling for the film’s boycott in the largest country in the world. You see, to them, Indiana Jones 4 is “crude, anti-Soviet propaganda that distorts history.”

No, they’re not complaining about the specifics within the Indiana Jones movie, which is clearly fiction from beginning to end, but instead about the depiction of Cate Blanchett as an evil KGB agent looking for a crystal skull that could give her unimaginable powers – along with a bunch of other mindless and “evil” KGB agents and Soviet soldiers. The following are quotes taken from a recent Communist meeting (according to the Reuters article):

“What galls is how together with America we defeated Hitler, and how we sympathized when Bin Laden hit them. But they go ahead and scare kids with Communists. These people have no shame.” Um, I’m pretty sure Communists have been used as villains in films for the last sixty years.

“Harrison Ford and Cate Blanchett (are) second-rate actors, serving as the running dogs of the CIA. We need to deprive these people of the right of entering the country.” Really? Wow.

“Our movie-goers are teenagers who are completely unaware of what happened in 1957. They will go to the cinema and will be sure that in 1957 we made trouble for the United States and almost started a nuclear war. It’s rubbish … In 1957 the communists did not run with crystal skulls throughout the U.S. Why should we agree to that sort of lie and let the West trick our youth?” OK, so maybe the Communists are attacking the plot of the movie. Arguments like these are ones that really send me over the deep end – if you’re going to take mindless entertainment so seriously, how can we possibly take your arguments seriously?

Ultimately, I find things like this ludicrous. Countries get offended by odd things, and it’s not always too surprising – after all, many countries have very strong national identities and don’t like it when films portray them in a negative light (Borat comes to mind). Hell, even some people in the U.S. get upset about anti-U.S. films (Bill O’Reilly, anyone?). Still, this is the first time I’ve heard of the defunct Russian Communist Party getting upset about such a blatantly harmless movie (though I’ve come to understand that there were also complaints about 1998’s Armageddon because the movie portrayed a derelict Russian space station). I mean, really, so many American and European movies have portrayed Soviets in a much more negative light, and usually to a higher degree of realism. The James Bond movies come to mind. Dozens of other quality films, too. Why get heated – and call for the ban of – Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull?

Silly Communists.

By Erik Samdahl
Related categories: Movies
Tags: , , ,

AROUND THE WEB

  • http://www.bugsycline.com bugsy

    hey dummy, at one point in America you were either a repulican, a democrat, an idependant or a communist.
    every heard of the green party?
    In some states (like mine Pennsylvania) in november You can vote for a green party candidate. the problem is the big three media companies that host debates (wich are run by either the DNC or the RNC) don’t want you to know that there are other parties. After all It wouldn’t sit well for all those OIl companies to have to give up them oil proffits to the people of the US instead of the pocketts of CEO fatcats

    If I’ve gone over your head I’ll break it down for you….

    Communism is alive and well here in the USA and has been for over 75 years. It is not the big evil that folks like J Edgar Hoover, Allen Dullas and other tyrants in US power have been trying to make you think it is. the cold war is a Holy war! Just like the one we have now with christians hating Muslims.
    Most Communists are Athiests. wich truth be told is the NUMBER ONE REASON the USA hates Communists. It shocks me how since the Bush administration has come to power how now we are all supposed to hate communism again and the evil commies are now terrorists.
    fyi Lucille Ball (“I love lucy” was a registered comunist, just like her father)

    this aside, at first I saw indy 4 after hearing Communists were upset. the first 20 minutes has a joke where indy smerks about how stupid the cia is in the fact they are destroying peoples lives just because of their communist veiws.
    but then about halfway through the flick we have a sceene where the evil russian chick is holding the skull and saying things like “with this we can infect the minds of millions of americans and turn them against each other slowly, without them even realising we are doing so”

    these kind of words do hit home hard to any communist for they are the type of words that the US propoganda machine has used for over 50 years to discredit the ideals of Communism. In the 50’s the cia would just march right into peoples homes and throw them in jail for voting communism, even though it used to be an option when you registered to vote and when you became draft age.

    fyi Bob Dylan was a communist!

    you see communist don’t beleive that people should ever starve, be homeless, be with out a higher education, be with out proper medical care because of their income. they also feel that the good for the community is their number one priority. In communism if a tyrant gains power, you will always see a revolt and the leader being removed by the people, instead of some tyrant like the Bush. whom can bomb and kill for oil in the name of God.

    Back to the movie. I loved Raiders. I love Indy. I liked seeing indy again. I hate the bogus cgi and the very small plot. the aliens were just stupid, but not as stupid as the abomb sequence.

    bottom line is, If some one made a movie where the plot contained a sceene where the “good guys” were bashing say African americans using the same rhetoric that the kkk spreads do you think that Black folks would have a right to be mad?

    this is 2008 it is time we realise that not everybody in the world shares the same Religion,Race,political veiws,gender etc… and starts accepting folks for the person they are.

    also, It sure would be nice if movie makers would stop de-faming all of our child hood hereos with trashy remakes and sequels.

  • http://www.filmjabber.com Erik Samdahl

    Hey Bugsy,

    Thanks for your comment. I don’t disagree with anything you said, really. I have nothing against communism, and in fact think that if a national could achieve true communism, that’d be a good thing. At the same time, I do not believe communism ideals can ever be achieved. Regardless of American propaganda against communism, history has time and time again proven that communism cannot be executed on a national level with its ideals intact. You say that “in communism if a tyrant gains power, you will always see a revolt and the leader being removed by the people.” This is true in regards to what the communist doctrine states; this is not true in how communism has actually been implemented. In every communist state that has actually existed, they have turned into dictatorships to some degree or another.

    Regardless of our views of communism, the point of the article was more my annoyance with the extremist fundamentalists of any belief. You do bring up a good point about what if the film was bashing African Americans and the good guys were the KKK, yet at the same time I think this goes on a case by case basis. The article was not intended to attack communists than to address Soviets (Russian Communists specifically) complaining about how they are depicted in the film. Soviets have been used as bad guys in countless films for fifty years, because they did, to some degree, “want to take over the world.” (I know that’s a very broad statement) The Soviet system ultimately began to fail because it was a flawed system.

    Basically, I find it silly that these people get worked up so much over the mild depiction of Soviets in the film that they are calling for the movie to be banned in the country. I have the same complaint about fundamentalist Christians who try to ban movies like Dogma, etc.

  • Pingback: giant twist comfort cs

MOVIE BLOG