I Still Know What You Did Last Summer Movie Review
Since Scream came out, several horror movies have arrived, trying to top its excellence, or at least it's box office earnings. Within a year, Scream 2 and I Know What You Did Last Summer appeared (within a month of each other). Urban Legend came a while later. I Know What You Did Last Summer didn't have the greatest of plots but it sufficed, providing lots of thrills and strong characters. It was only inevitable that a sequel would arrive, and that time has come. I Still Know What You Did Last Summer tries to top, or match, its predecessor, much like Scream 2 did Scream, but something went wrong.
I was quite excited when I heard about a sequel way back in May and highly anticipated the day when I would be able to go see it. Jennifer Love Hewitt is one of my favorite actresses, both on the big screen and in "Party of Five": She's beautiful, sexy, and talented. There was nothing wrong with her in this movie, except that the director seemed to spend more care putting her in wet, unbuttoned clothing than the movie itself.
The things required for a successful sequel in the horror genre are more deaths, more intricate deaths, and at least some originality. I Still Know What You Did Last Summer fails in most of these, and then some. A lot more people are killed in this movie but every death is similar: Willis strikes them down with his hook, or some other sharp object. The most suspenseful moments are where Julie is searching rooms, knowing someone is lurking in the shadows, which, unfortunately, happens way too much. Every scene is repetitive: Julie is either looking for the killer or someone is getting gouged by a hook. It doesn't get any better.
There is no character support in I Still Know What You Did Last Summer. In the first one, everyone felt sorry for Sarah Michelle Gellar as she was sliced only a few feet away from safety. In this one, there are no such extravagant deaths, nor do you feel for the characters. The characters are all cliched for the most part and there are only four of them, including Hewitt. And, of course, there was that chubby drug guy who only made this movie worse.
Last but not least came the ending. The ending would have been good- if we hadn't already seen it (and better) in the original Scream. It wasn't predictable but it soon becomes obvious that the screenwriters were lacking any original ideas. Of course, that was obvious from the first half-hour.
Though I Still Know What You Did Last Summer provided some creepy suspense, most of it was cheap thrills, and there were too many flaws to make it any good. I was sorely disappointed by this film and would suggest any of the other slasher movies of the last two years over this one.
Review by Erik Samdahl unless otherwise indicated.