Grizzly Man (2005) - Movie Review
NA
Perhaps you've heard about Timothy Treadwell, a bear activist who spent many years living alongside grizzly bears in Alaska until he stayed one day too long and, along with his girlfriend Amie Huguenard, was eaten by one. "Grizzly Man," directed and narrated by Werner Herzog, combines interviews and archival footage to show what drove Treadwell and offers up some explanations as to why he risked his life.
As documentaries should, the movie offers up a balanced view of Treadwell, a man who loved the creatures he lived with so much that'd he'd do anything for them. He viewed himself as their protector, but as he became more passionate about the subject many say he crossed the line. Some say that by living with the bears he made them accustomed to humans when they shouldn't be, and his complete disregard for laws and his own safety resulted in his own downfall. On top of everything else, Treadwell definitely had some mental problems - as the movie shows, he was quite a nutjob.
"Grizzly Man" is captivating on so many levels. It's amazing to see wild grizzlies up close and a human being all but hugging them. They are magnificent creatures, even if they can be dangerous, as to simply see them in nature is something. Then, to have a man who cares so much about them is pretty impressive; Treadwell talks with them like they're pets, and seems completely oblivious to how deadly they can be even when he says so out loud. As the movie progresses, our image of Treadwell gets more and more skewed, as isolation and his unprecedented love for the bears take their toll. He goes on several rants, many quite extreme, about various subjects. The movie also explores his psychological history to explain why he did the things he did.
The movie only stumbles in one sequence, where a medical examiner explains in great detail what he thinks happened to Treadwell and Huguenard in their last moments. I couldn't tell whether this guy was for real or not, but his speech sounded dramatized and scripted. The scene seemed completely out-of-place, though perhaps this was to make up for Herzog's decision not to include the audio tape of Treadwell's last moments. This might sound a bit sick, but I got so involved with the film that I would have liked to hear it.
"Grizzly Man" is a captivating film that explores nature and its effect on man. Within the movie you can literally watch Treadwell spiral out of control, ultimately ending in his death.
Comments
No HTML. Be kind - your mom might read what you say.
Home |
Movies |
Movie Reviews |
Blog |
Media |
DVD |
Contests |
Links |
About Us |
Contact Us  Movie reviews © 2003-2009 Erik Samdahl. All other content © of its respected owner. Read our Privacy Policy |
Anonymous says:
November 22, 2005I feel kind of odd reviewing a movie so close to my nom de plume (Griz Bear Man--no, my real name is NOT Doug Peacock, either, so don't get any ideas, especially since he can write whereas I cannot write worth a crap). I feel odd, especially since I get out in the wilderness where the grizzly roams and occasionally see one.
Werner Herzog does one hell of a job of documentary film making, portraying the controversial, somewhat mentally unbalanced but still inspiring, troubling figure of Timothy Treadwell, a man I've personally met and liked. And Herzog does so convincingly and with real depth. Like Treadwell, I am a ferocious advocate of protecting grizzlies and their habitat; unlike him, I don't consider grizzlies my friends--I know they hate me and have good reason to hate me and will kill me if I don't behave myself in their country. Grizzlies teach me respect, and teach us humans some boundaries that we just don't cross, which is why I want to keep grizzlies around--to keep us in our place.
Unfortunately, Mr. Treadwell did not repsect these boundaries, which Mr. Herzog takes pains to point out. Yet Herzog strikes as much of a balance as a film-maker can with such a mercurial subject, showing Treadwell to be a nut case, but also a man Herzog admires for how he exemplifies the human search for meaning and, moreover, found what he was looking for--even if he paid a stiff price for that. Herzog makes deft use of Treadwell's own footage to flesh out his portrait of this complicated man--we see that Treadwell did have an ability to somehow get bears to learn to trust him and tolerate his close proximity (in one scene a curious cub comes right up to Treadwell, who gently tells the cub to go away and "go play" but the mother does not seem agitated, only watchful).
Herzog also leaves us thinking harder about the proper human relationship with the natural world. Now, I don't like some of Herzog's attitudes--he brings his German superiority-of-culture sensibility to the film , which comes out when he makes the statement that, in contrast to Treadwell who saw an Edenic beauty and harmony in nature, Herzog sees chaos and brute indifference with the further implication being that civilization represents order. Poppycock! Civilization, especially modern industrial civilization, is on the verge of plunging the whole world into chaos, especially ecological chaos--civilization's only hope is to acknowledge its roots in the natural world. Herzog then later reinforces his poppycock attitude by criticizing Treadwell for his hostility to civilization. Well, Treadwell is sometimes way over the top (witness his profanity-laced diatribe against the Park Service in the film), but he may have good reason for being one of civilization's discontents, given the threat civilization poses to grizzlies in particular, and global ecological integrity in general. In this, Herzog may be as naive in his own way as Treadwell is in his. In short, Herzog does not get it, especially when it comes to wilderness or bears--he seems to think bears are unfeeling brutes intrested only in food, even as he acknowledges their beauty and grace. But I will not let these shortcomings detract from a superlative documentary film. Treadwell pushed the envelope maybe too far in trying to get the rest of humanity to regain their lost relationship with wild nature in a civilization that is in many ways deliberately hostile to the natural world and has alienated humans from their own nature as well as from the natural world. To his credit, Herzog allows the viewer to see this and to see that we would be well-advised not to love bears the way Timothy did, or we'll end up dead and deservedly so, but we ARE well advised to love and accept bears for what they are and leave them well-enough alone to live wild, to live free.